#47 Original Over Remake (#54)

Today I finished reading my 54th book of the year, and 38th of the 2015 Reading Challenge (#47 A play): ‘Antigone’ by Jean Anouilh. This marked the second book for my MA English, which I have to compare directly with the original play by Sophocles for my first essay of the course. Up until this point I have always been a believer that the original trumps any remakes, and it’s fair to say that that belief still stands…

My Goodreads Review
“‘Antigone’ by Jean Anouilh is a 1940s play based on the original version by Sophocles. It is set in France during the German occupation, and as a result there is a largely political motivation driving the play.
The story-arc is largely identical to the original, with the exception that there is more ambiguity towards who the more moral of the characters are: whilst Antigone is the unquestionable heroine in the Sophocles play, the audience tendency leans towards Creon as being the more socially balanced individual in the Anouilh version.
The play commences following the deaths of Antigone’s brothers Etéocles and Polynices, the ruler(s) of the nation. Following their death, their uncle Creon ascends to power: unlike the Sophocles version where he was presented as a power-hungry individual, in this work he states that he never wanted the responsibility (largely due to the German occupation and the resistance). As with the original, Antigone swears loyalty to her brothers and accepts her fate of death to ensure her disgraced brother Polynices a proper burial. Unlike the original, the Anouilh version sees a more intense debate play out between Antigone and Creon as to reasons to live and die.
This reworking was not as enjoyable as the original, largely due to the reasonings and behaviours of the characters.”

IMG_3240

Content: David Tennant and Sophocles annihilate Matt Smith and Anouilh

It wasn’t a bad play by any stretch of the imagination, but I didn’t enjoy the time period in which it was set, and I didn’t think the characters actions were as believable as in the Sophocles version. I’m definitely excited (and very daunted) about writing my essay comparing these two plays – it’s due four weeks today, I’d better get a move on!

#47 A play – Antigone by Jean Anouilh (4/10)

Thirty-eight down, twelve to go. (Fifty-four read)

My journey will also be instagrammed frequently on @charlottebibliophile

This entry was posted in General Musings and tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to #47 Original Over Remake (#54)

  1. Pingback: Reading Wrap-Up: November 2015 | charlottebibliophile (It Does Not Do To Dwell On Dreams And Forget To Live)

  2. Pingback: Successes and Failures: Top Ten Books On My Fall TBR | charlottebibliophile (It Does Not Do To Dwell On Dreams And Forget To Live)

  3. Pingback: Quarter Quell #4 | charlottebibliophile (It Does Not Do To Dwell On Dreams And Forget To Live)

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s